ridenrace6 wrote:
i dont think the engine size idea will work any better than the qualifying idea
1. it will take a while to p&g 30 - 40 buggies and anybody can change engines from one race to the next so it will need to be done at every race and these events take a good bit of time and we/they try to figure out ways to make them go by faster not take longer
2. the honor system aint worth a crap either, if it did there wouldnt be any sandbagging going on in the first place
3. engine size dont necesarily = more horsepower, ive got a 1915 that will smoke my 2332 and ive also got a 2500 that will smoke a buddy of mines 2500 on almost identical setup buggy and trannys
4. more horsepower and better trannys are only part of the equation, a bad handling/setup buggy usually only gets worse with more
5. regardless of the buggy and its parts list driver skill means about as much, if not more, than the buggy does, i know a man that can take a 1835 and go places a lot of folks including myself cant or wont go with bigger motors and he will make it look like a cake walk
6. the best driver with the worst buggy can run with the worst driver with the best buggy
the qualify system would work just fine IF the honor sytem worked imo
my suggestion is put averaging of the times back in like last year to "help out" the honor system
my 2 cents
1. Wouldn't take that long to P&G 30-40 buggies if the competitors helped. They can pull a plug out and then wouldn't take long at all to actually put the gauge on them. And anyone changing a motor at the hill would be noticed I think. They would have to go somewhere else to do it.
2. No argument whatsoever.
3. Old saying, no replacement for displacement. While I agree to a point, a well built 1915 can and will perform better than a 2332 that has stock parts aside of the pistons and jugs. But if they are equally built, the 2332 should blow away the 1915.
4. No argument here neither. My idea was just to try and get buggies competiting together that are at least remotely close. No different from racing, your car will fall into a particular class due to engine size, and a few other things. If your car handles poorly, thats on you. But you are still at least running against roughly the same.
5. No argument here either. This applies to everything.
6. Trees make up a difference here. Lol.
Yeah, if the honor system worked 100%, everything would be great. However, we all know it doesn't always work this way. The averaging times could work, but then that can disqualify people that had a poor running engine during qualifing, they get time and get the problem solved, run the same hill because of a poor qual time and blow it out of the water.
These are just my thoughts. It is how many sanctioned motorsports are run. While nothing will be perfect and satisfy everyone, it at least places buggies roughly in the same performance groups. I know there are hundreds of other factors.